In this
educational mythbuster we will be examining the myth of "Do certain people
learn better certain ways?". Over the years within the classroom you would
hear students or fellow classmates saying, I learn best *this way*..., but is
that really the case? In this post we will investigate if this is a true or
false statement. I know I have the belief that I do learn best by verbal and
visual instruction, but is that really true?
The answer is no according to the
Association for Psychological Science. Some students will learn better when
material is presented visually and that others will learn better when the
material is presented verbally, or even in some other way is a myth (Learning
Styles Debunked: There is No Evidence Supporting Auditory and Visual Learning,
Psychologists Say. Retrieved October 02, 2016, from
http://www.psychologicalscience.org/index.php/news/releases/learning-styles-debunked-there-is-no-evidence-supporting-auditory-and-visual-learning-psychologists-say.html).
In the Psychological Science in the Public Interest a new major
report was released saying that “auditory learners” and “visual learners”
are not a valid type of learning description. In the cases where past studies
have supported those ideas, they did not use the type of randomized
research designs to make it valid (Hall, E. (2016). The tenacity of learning
styles: a response to Lodge, Hansen, and Cottrell. Learning: Research and
Practice, 2(1), 18-26.).
The claim that
we have to adapt our design to accommodate different learning styles has been
repeatedly debunked by research (Finley, T. (2015). Are Learning Styles Real - and Useful?
Retrieved October 02, 2016, from http://www.edutopia.org/article/learning-styles-real-and-useful-todd-finley).
Learning styles were just something that were a popularized idea. Teachers
should recognize not all students learn the same but also there are no set
categories to place different types of learning in. Just like in any concept of
school and teaching, all students should not be shoved into a generic “cookie
cutter”, but rather all treated as individuals.
Although this
myth is busted a suggestion to counter these old ideas, is to support active learning.
This is the idea that students must take control of their learning, regardless
of the way the material is presented to them, “People must learn to
recognize when they understand and when they need more information” (Bransford,
J. D., Brown, A. L., & Cocking, R. R. (2000). How people learn.). As
a teacher we all want our students to be proactive, so the next question we
would need to answer is how to do this, how do we get our students to not peg
themselves as a specific type of learner but rather become a constant learner.
Good post! I really like your last paragraph and how to argue this point, by simply stating the need to be a constant learner.
ReplyDeleteI personally feel that we can all learn in many ways but whether one calls it learning styles or learning preferences, I definitely struggle to learn new concepts when not taught to my learning preference. Whatever its called, based on the current study at the time, it makes a difference to me when I learn. However Dr. Jason Siko, the Ed. Tech. program director feels very strongly the opposite. What do you think?
(I just read your iPPT prior to this post. Is your favorite color blue?) :D